The Shunning (Heritage of Lancaster County #1) by Beverly Lewis Katie Lapp discovers a family secret that challenges her Amish upbringing, leading to questions of faith, identity, and forbidden love in a traditional community.
Plain Perfect (Daughters of the Promise #1) by Beth Wiseman
A young Amish woman struggles with perfectionism and hidden pain, finding healing and unexpected romance through faith and vulnerability in her close-knit settlement.
The Choice (The Amish of Lancaster County #1) by Suzanne Woods Fisher
A widow returns to her Amish roots after tragedy, facing old wounds and new love while learning that forgiveness and God’s plan can restore hope.
When the Morning Comes (Sisters of the Quilt #2) by Cindy Woodsmall
Hannah Lapp flees her Amish life for love outside the community, grappling with heartbreak, secrets, and rediscovering faith in a world of change.
A Daughter’s Redemption by Shelley Shepard Gray
A woman returns home to care for her ailing father, confronting past mistakes and finding redemption through quiet romance and renewed trust in God.
The Keeper (Stoney Ridge Seasons #1) by Suzanne Woods Fisher In a community where love is tested by duty, a young woman guards her heart until an outsider challenges her to embrace both faith and romance.
Amish Cinderella by Ashley Emma
A modern twist on the classic tale: an Amish woman hides her heritage while falling for an “English” man, blending fairy-tale charm with faith and family secrets.
The First Love (Sisters of Holmes County #1) by Wanda E. Brunstetter
A shy Amish girl discovers courage and first love when an accident forces her to step outside her comfort zone, highlighting God’s timing in relationships.
A Man of His Word (Plain City Peace #1) by Kim Vogel Sawyer
A widower and a young woman navigate grief and new beginnings in an Amish world, learning that love and faith can heal even the deepest wounds.
The Miracle of Hope by Cindy Woodsmall
Characters face loss and uncertainty, finding miraculous hope through prayer, community support, and a tender romance grounded in biblical principles.
Plain Pursuit by Alison Stone
An “English” woman returns to her Amish roots for answers about her past, sparking romance and spiritual growth amid family mysteries.
The Amish Nanny by Mindy Starns Clark
A nanny caring for Amish children uncovers family secrets, leading to romance and a deeper walk with God in a peaceful rural setting.
A Perfect Amish Romance (Berlin Bookmobile #1) by Shelley Shepard Gray
A bookmobile driver in an Amish community helps patrons find more than books—sparking gentle romance, friendship, and faith journeys.
The Amish Widow’s Heart by Rachel J. Good
A grieving widow opens her heart to healing and new love, supported by her faith community and God’s comforting presence.
Love Comes to Paradise by Mary Ellis
In a new settlement, a young woman seeks belonging and romance while navigating cultural adjustments and spiritual growth.
The Amish Midwife by Mindy Starns Clark and Leslie Gould
A midwife’s calling intertwines with romance and mystery, emphasizing service, faith, and love in the Amish way of life.
A Simple Amish Christmas by Vannetta Chapman
Holiday traditions bring together estranged family members, leading to reconciliation, romance, and renewed faith during Christmas.
The Amish Groom by Mindy Starns Clark
A young man questions his future in the Amish world, finding love and purpose through faith and unexpected connections.
When Hearts Collide by Ruth Reid
Forbidden attraction tests two young people from different paths, leading to choices about love, community, and following God’s will.
The Amish Christmas Candle by Kelly Irvin
A collection of holiday stories where candlelight symbolizes hope, drawing couples together through faith, forgiveness, and seasonal romance.